On
the Trail of the ‘Elusive’ Lillian and Marion Morehouse* Unraveling
the Genealogical Mysteries of the World's First Supermodel, by
Rob Couteau. |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
While preparing to interview the E. E. Cummings’s biographer Christopher
Sawyer-Lauçanno, I became intrigued by the figure of Marion Morehouse (the poet’s
lifelong companion), or perhaps I should say by her nebulousness. In the
late Twenties and early Thirties, before meeting Cummings in 1932, Marion was
one of the most widely recognized fashion models of the day, appearing in both
Vogue and Vanity Fair. The renowned photographer Edward Steichen
called her “the greatest fashion model I ever shot,” adding: “Miss Morehouse was
no more interested in fashions as fashions than I was. But when she put on the
clothes that were to be photographed, she transformed herself into a woman who
really would wear that gown or that riding habit or whatever the outfit.” She
was also a favorite of the photographers Cecil Beaton and Baron George Hoyningen-Huene.
Two years before her death, Beaton wrote: It was not until Miss Marion Morehouse was discovered by Steichen that photographic models became so well known that they exerted an influence on the public. The aim of models at this time was to be grand ladies, and Marion Morehouse, with her particularly personal ways of twisting her neck, her fingers and feet, was at home in the grandest circumstances. These
quotations were each included in Marion’s ample, two-column New York Times
obit, “Marion Morehouse Cummings, Poet’s Widow, Top Model, Dies.” The title of
the obit could just as easily have been phrased, “First Top Model.” In
the words of Tobia Bezzola, a curator at the Kunsthaus Zürich, Steichen’s “mannequins
– even if they were not stars of stage and screen – became recognizable personalities.
In his collaboration with Marion Morehouse, he in effect laid the groundwork for
the idea of an identifiable supermodel.”* In The Model as Muse: Embodying Fashion,
Harold Koda, the Curator in Charge at New York’s Metropolitan Museum of Art, places
the careers of Morehouse and Steichen in a broader cultural context: Cultural awareness of modeling as a respectable,
stand-alone profession was slow in coming…. [and] it was not until the mid-1920s
that the fashion model began to emerge as a fully formed social and professional
entity. One event in particular – a model search organized in New York by Vogue
in 1924 for the visiting French couturier Jean Patou – signaled, perhaps, that
society had finally recognized that fashion presentations featuring live models
not only advanced the agenda of the industry, but also provided women with viable
career opportunities. Among those discovered in the process of selecting from
more than 500 applicants hoping to join Patou’s cabine were Miriam Hopkins,
Ann Andrews, Dorothy Smoller, Lily Tosch, and Marion Morehouse – the latter, though
not selected by Patou, was certainly noticed by Vogue and would appear
to have been chosen by fate. With Morehouse’s meteoric ascent, America witnessed
the beginning of the model’s rise to international fame and eventual influence
upon feminine beauty and popular culture. Confident, emancipated, and unapologetically
liberated, Morehouse’s image was as fresh and exciting to the young sophisticates
of the 1920s as it was alarming to the old establishment. When Edward Steichen
was hired at Vogue in 1923 to replace [Adolphe] de Meyer, his innovative
modernist photographic style ripped through twentieth-century visual culture like
a searing knife. Almost overnight, de Meyer’s painterly pictorialist images were
thrust into the past as Steichen introduced the twentieth century to the modern
woman by way of unerring clarity and his favorite model – Marion Morehouse. Embodying the adventurous and self-directed
lifestyles celebrated in magazine and novels of the era, [model Lee] Miller and
Morehouse in many ways symbolized the fully realized, progressive attitudes of
the 1920s. Living examples of the newly liberated modern American woman, they
put a face on a generation intent upon turning their backs once and for all on
still-lingering Victorian sexism and the last gasps of Edwardian propriety – sentiments
that fashion (no matter how high hemlines might rise) could only hint at. Doing
much to temper the more frivolous connotations of the out-all-night, free-spirited
flapper, Marion Morehouse and Lee Miller – with their cool, nonchalant elegance
and confident, unaffected smiles directed right into the lens – projected refreshingly
frank and fearlessly modern attitudes, and heralded not only changes in fashion,
but also a new way of living for American women.* Koda’s
book was published in 2009 to coincide with the exhibit “The Model as Muse,” featured
at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. More recently, a September 2010 article by
Robin Muir in FirstFT magazine, “Vogue’s Earliest Celebrity Models,” expanded
on this theme: That models became so recognizable that they began to fascinate the public
is often traced back to Marion Morehouse. And with justification. She was not
an actress or a society figure but something new entirely, a dedicated model,
and Vogue began to use her name in credit lines.* Yet Marion had managed to cloak so many
details of her personal life for so many decades that Cummings’s previous biographer,
Richard Kennedy, had at times clearly thrown his hands up in exasperation. In
an essay titled “The Elusive Marion Morehouse,” he complained of “a great many
obstacles” that were placed in his way while working on his thirty-year project,
adding: “The principal obstacle was Marion Morehouse herself.” This was the case
even more so when the subject was Marion instead of Cummings: “Whenever I would
ask her a specific question about some feature of her life, she would raise a
warning finger against my inquiry…. It was not until after her death that I was
able to begin my real biographical research.” Kennedy adds: “My gathering of information
about her had to start with the facts set down in her obituary, a course that
gradually raised questions in my mind about the persona she had created for herself
during her lifetime.” Indeed, one glance at her Times obituary reveals
several key errors that took root as a result of these obfuscations, the biggest
one being the year of her birth. Kennedy himself was suspicious on this score:
“In Edward Steichen’s photograph of her, made for Vogue magazine in 1925,
she was supposedly only nineteen years old; yet she looks much older.”* Unable to track down a March 9, 1906 birth certificate for Marion in
South Bend, Indiana, Kennedy also failed to find one for 1905 or 1904. As I would
soon discover, even if he’d gone back another year, to 1903 – the actual date
of her birth, according to census records I eventually unearthed – he still would
have come up empty handed, at least in South Bend. A county clerk with whom I
recently spoke said that birth certificates were not legally required in Indiana
until about 1906 or 1907, so most of the “home births” (the majority of births
in the state, at that time) remained unrecorded. Marion’s obit also erroneously
reports that she and Edward Estlin Cummings were married and that Marion attended
St. Anne’s Academy in Hartford: a school that, according to Kennedy, never even
existed. Almost twenty-five years had passed since
Kennedy’s Dreams in the Mirror:
Biography of E. E. Cummings had first
appeared. As an avid genealogist, I realized that online resources for family
research had snowballed into tremendous proportions in just the last ten years.
Thus, when Christopher Sawyer-Lauçanno’s E.
E. Cummings: A Biography was published in 2004 – a lyrical and informative
work that successfully builds upon Kennedy’s foundation – much of this genealogical
material still remained unavailable. When I contacted Christopher in July of 2014
and raised the possibility of finding something new, he enthusiastically gave
me his blessing to start digging. What followed in just the next few hours
was one of those uncanny serendipities that resonate with the allure of a Sherlock
Holmes episode. First, I had a look at the obit that had sent Kennedy on a trip
down the rabbit hole. As a genealogist, my eye instinctively lingered on the names
of the other family members mentioned therein: a sister, Lillian, who had refused
to speak with Kennedy after Marion’s death, leading him to “wonder about what
family secrets were being protected,” and a brother, Benjamin. Logging into “Ancestry.com,” after a search for a family tree on Marion yielded nothing of note, I tried to find something on Lillian. (Although Marion was included in most of the E. E. Cummings pedigrees, none revealed the names of her parents or anything of interest about her background.) Then I stumbled upon a lodestone. A listing for “Lillian Morehouse Cox” appeared on Ancestry, and it was cross-linked to a web site that I’d found helpful in the past. “Find-a-Grave.com”
revealed that Lillian was buried in a cemetery in Bloomfield, Connecticut, along
with several other Morehouses. (The site allows members to erect online memorials
for the deceased, including vital statistics and photographs.) And
a memorial for Lillian contained three amazing portraits. One was a snapshot taken
of Lillian, her brother Benjamin, and her mother, who appeared to be in her seventies.
The other two photos were professionally composed. One was captioned, “Lillian
modeling circa 1920s,” and it featured a tall, slender, willowy figure wearing
a satin dress with a matching cape, with her bobbed hair cut short in the style
of the flappers. The last picture was the most amazing of all: the bust of an
beguiling young woman, perhaps eighteen to twenty years old, with pale, opalescent
skin, an oval face, full lips, a prominent nose, long flowing hair, and an utterly
entrancing expression as she gazes off, into the distance. The caption reads:
“Actress Lillian Morehouse Cox.” None
of these intriguing images had ever appeared in print. In addition, Lillian’s
birth was listed as March 31, 1906: the same month and year that her sister, Marion,
claimed to have been born. Although Richard Kennedy had expressed doubts about
the family actually hailing from South Bend, the memorial states that Lillian
was indeed born there – and that she was the “daughter of Benjamin and Anna Morehouse.”
When I shared this information with Christopher Sawyer-Lauçanno, he excitedly
confirmed that the names of Marion’s parents had never been known to any of Cummings’s
biographers. And there was no doubt the memorial was referencing the same family.
A bio on Lillian said she was The sister of Marion Morehouse Cummings, the
wife of poet e. e. cummings. Also a brother Benjamin Morehouse. Lillian was a
model and stage actress. Lillian was married on August 3, 1928 to Alan B. Cox
in New Jersey. They divorced in June 8, 1942 in Miami, Florida, St. Joseph County. An additional note indicated that the memorial
was created by one Tony Ungaro on February 16, 2009. Just as I’d suspected, all
this was relatively new information. With these crucial facts in hand, I returned to Ancestry and began to dig up additional data. Most importantly, I located Lillian and Marion in a 1910 U. S. Federal Census taken in Connecticut, which shows that Marion was then seven years old and was born in Indiana to “Annie” Morehouse. Lillian’s age was off by a year: on April 15, 1910, she was actually four years old, but the enumerator has written “3.” (Her birth in 1906 was later confirmed by her death certificate.) The census also includes their brother, Benjamin, who was two, thus born in 1908. The family was then living at 20 Centre Street, in Hartford. Although it said Anna was married, her husband wasn’t listed along with the rest of the family. Instead, “Benjamin I. Morehouse” appears in the 1910 census recorded in South Bend, living at 810 North Lafayette Street with his seventy-four-year-old father, John Morehouse, his sixty-four year old mother, Elizabeth, and three of his younger siblings. According to this document, he’s married; and under a column headed “Number of Years of Present Marriage,” the enumerator has written “7.”* I
next contacted a clerk named “Chuck” at the Mount Saint Benedict Cemetery. A brief
telephone conversation confirmed the accuracy of the memorial data and revealed
that Lillian was buried in the same plot as her brother, Benjamin Jr, and Anna
Shortell Morehouse, their mother, who died in 1965. Anna’s husband died first,
in 1954, and he was buried with Anna Halpin, Anna
Shortell’s mother, in another part of the cemetery. An
obituary in the online Hartford Courant newspaper states that “Lillian (Morehouse)
Cox, of Hartford, died Tuesday (May 31, 1994) in Hartford Hospital. She was born
in Hartford, daughter of the late Isaac and Anna (Shortell) Morehouse.” Another
edition of the paper, published on May 28, 2000, featured an article about local
celebrities and people of note who are interred in the vicinity. Titled “The Sweet
Hereafter,” it features these consecutive paragraphs: Isaac Benjamin Morehouse (1870-1954), Mount
St. Benedict Cemetery, Bloomfield. He was an actor on the vaudeville stage. Lillian
M. Morehouse (1906-1994), Mount St. Benedict Cemetery, Bloomfield. She was an
actress and model, and the sister-in-law of e.e. cummings. As I would eventually discover, the reversal of Mr. Morehouse’s first
and middle name appears throughout his life, and on several key documents, such
as his first marriage certificate and his death certificate (the latter lists
Lillian as the “informant”). On his son’s birth certificate, under “Father’s Name,”
the clerk had initially typed “Isaac,” but then he crossed it out and replaced
it with “Benjamin.” After
spending the next few days collecting additional information and constructing
a basic family tree, I contacted Tony Ungaro via e-mail. I explained that I was
preparing to interview Professor Sawyer-Lauçanno, and that I hoped we could speak.
A genial former executive from Hartford, Tony telephoned the following day, on
August 5, 2014. And he had quite a story to tell. Tony was formerly employed as an executive
for the Heublein Corporation in Hartford, where Lillian Morehouse worked in a
clerical position. (“We manufactured A1 Steak Sauce, Smirnoff Vodka, and Grey
Poupon mustard.”) During this period, Tony had no idea that Lillian was related
to the wife of E. E. Cummings. Although they didn’t know each other that well,
he would occasionally “help her out with a ride home from work,” for which she
was quite grateful. After
thirty-four years at Heublein, Tony retired in March 1994, his last position being
Manager of Period Cost Control. (“I developed and managed ninety-million dollars
in budgets.”) Four months later, he moved with his wife to Sarasota, Florida.
After Lillian passed away in May of that year, he received a probate letter from
her lawyer in West Hartford, which informed him that Lillian had remembered him
in her will. Quite surprised by all this, Tony replied that he didn’t want any
money – but that he would be happy to receive some mementos. Shortly
afterward, a UPS truck delivered three large boxes containing letters, photographs,
and divorce papers. There were also “photo albums going back to the 1800s, and
many very personal letters,” including some that had been exchanged between Lillian’s
parents. As we spoke, Mr. Ungaro remained eminently discreet about the contents
of some of these letters. “The mother and father experienced serious difficulties
and were separated for a time,” he said, but he didn’t get any more specific than
that regarding the contents of these missives – and I didn’t press the matter.
He added that many of the letters exchanged between Anna and Benjamin were so
personal that he decided to destroy them. When we spoke a second time, about seven
months later, he was more specific: the letters concerned great financial hardship,
and the separation he was referring to occurred in the Thirties, when Lillian
was in a hospital in New York. (More on this later.) This dovetails with the contents
of the 1930 U. S. Federal Census, which shows that Benjamin was married and living
with his mother, Elizabeth, at 302 Hawthorne Drive, in South Bend. Anna doesn’t
appear in the census, although a city directory from this period says that she
officially resided at the same address. Therefore, she may have been in the hospital
during this period. Retaining
only a small file of mementoes for himself, the remainder he forwarded to a relative
of Lillian’s that he tracked down in Indiana.
Tony constructed a pedigree based on what he’d found in the family documents,
which he emailed me that same day. This allowed me make rapid progress in assembling
an even broader genealogy. When
I asked if there was anything else of note in the boxes, Tony said there were
a few small pieces of artwork, including pastels, which were created by Cummings
and which he also sent to Lillian’s relative. (Early in his career, Cummings was
a well-respected visual artist; and besides composing portraits of Marion he continued
to dabble in the arts later in his life.) Attached to the pedigree that Tony had shared
with me were a handful of photos of Marion and her family that have never appeared
in public before. The first was a head shot of Lillian’s father, Benjamin I. Morehouse,
whom Tony referred to as “Isaac.” Tony said that the letters and memorabilia also
revealed that “Isaac was a vaudeville actor who was “known for his ability to
go from ‘black face’ to white in just minutes.” An oval-shaped portrait, the photo
appeared to be printed on a flier or publicity sheet of some sort, with lettering
embossed on the paper beside it. (Although the image I received was cropped, the
letters “BE” – perhaps the first two letters of his name – appear to the right
of the picture). Tony’s photo archive also gives us an intimate look at the other
members of the Morehouse family, and it includes the only known image of Marion
posing with her sister, which appears to be the earliest extent photo of Marion.
In the family tree that Tony created, there
was also a note regarding a nuptial ceremony of some sort that had occurred between
Benjamin and Anna in a church in the Bronx. When I remarked that this was “well
after the birth of their children,” Tony said it “may have been after the fact,”
but that, given the difficulties experienced by Anna and Benjamin, “nothing would
surprise me.” I later contacted the church and obtained a record of this event,
which proved to be a marriage. I should add that there was no other record of
their marriage in any online database, and the church’s files from this period
were not digitalized. If Tony hadn’t inherited Lillian’s papers, I doubt anyone
would have found a trace of this event, especially since there was no clue that
the couple might have remarried ten years after the birth of their last child. Lillian had bequeathed Tony $10,000 (of
which he received $4,000), and she willed her doctor $40,000. She also left money
to her two caretakers. She’d amassed about $280,000, which utterly surprised Mr.
Ungaro, since she was employed merely as a clerk. But he added that, after Marion
died, the copyright of Cummings’s work went to Lillian, to the chagrin of Cummings’s
daughter (Nancy Thayer). Much of this had been depleted, however, by medical care
for her and her brother, Benjamin, so the amounts received by those in the will
were “less than specified.” Tony was amused by the fact that, when Lillian’s doctor
eventually moved to Chicago, “she was angry at him for leaving her.” When I noted
that Lillian hadn’t left anything to her distant relatives, he concluded that
this was probably due to their estrangement. Mr. Ungaro struck me as a completely trustworthy,
thoughtful, and down-to-earth fellow. During our conversation, I could hear his
wife occasionally speaking in the background, adding whatever she could to help
trigger his memory. Although he was aware of the famous poet and his work (“E.
E. Cummings wrote with those little letters, you know?”), he remained more interested
in Lillian and in carefully preserving her memory. I respected his decision to
honor the privacy of Lillian’s parents but, at the same time, to be as helpful
as possible while doing so. In
the months ahead, each of Mr. Ungaro’s leads checked out. I was able to obtain
various birth, marriage, and death certificates that verified his claims, and
I eventually managed to extend the genealogy of both Anna Shortell and Benjamin
Morehouse back a generation. I also located Anna and Benjamin’s death certificates,
which list the names of each of their parents, thus confirming Tony’s pedigree
data. City directories from Hartford and South Bend reveal precise locations where
they lived, and they also chronicle Benjamin’s various professions. Census results
from Indiana, New York, and Connecticut helped to fill in other gaps. By the fall
of 2014, I was able to reconstruct much of the background of Marion, Lillian,
and their antecedents. These are some of the main events: • According to the 1910 and 1930 census,
Marion Morehouse was born in Indiana in 1903. The 1910 census, taken in Hartford,
reveals that her mother, “Annie Morehouse,” was married and was the head of the
family. Note the absence of a husband in this listing, who would normally be considered
as the head. Strangely enough, under a column for the “Number of Years of Present
Marriage,” the enumerator has left the space blank, although it’s filled in for
each of the other married couples on the page. Perhaps this indicates a separation
just two years after the birth of Benjamin Jr. • In the 1930 census, taken when Marion
was twenty-seven, she was living on her own, renting a room at 5 Prospect Place,
in the Bronx. Although the original building is no longer there, it must have
been a high-rise, as there were 334 other “households” at this address. The enumerator
notes Marion’s “Occupation” as “Actress,” her “Industry” as the “Theatre” (spelled
the European way). Under “Class of Worker,” she’s considered a “Wage or salary
worker.” We also learn that she lived without a radio. • Apparently, Marion didn’t start fibbing
about her age to the census takers until 1940, when she informed an enumerator
that she was born in 1918, making her twenty-two instead of thirty-seven
years old. (Oddly enough, 1918 is the same year that her
parents remarried.) One wonders if E. E. Cummings was standing within earshot
and Marion was merely propagating a myth that even her lifelong companion had
remained unaware of. Upon learning this, Christopher Sawyer-Lauçanno remarked
that, all along, he had the impression that Marion kept many things a secret from
Cummings. “My sense,” he said, “is that he didn’t know much of any of this.” (Of
course, one must also allow for the possibly of a simple error on the part of
the enumerator, which was common.) Although Marion’s surname is misspelled (“Moorehouse”),
it’s undoubtedly her, for it correctly lists her address as 4 Patchin Place, the
small mews where she and Estlin Cummings maintained separate apartments for many
years. (Cummings first moved into 4 Patchin Place on September 8, 1924.) And consistent with the 1910 and 1930 census results, it records
her birthplace as “Indiana.” Under “Marital Status,” it says that Marion was single.
Her occupation is “Model,” her industry is “Artist Model.” Under “Highest Grade Completed,” we read: “High
school, 4th year.” This is contradicted by the 1930 census, which indicates, under
“Attended School,” “No.” But the 1910 census, taken when she was seven years old,
shows that Marion was then enrolled in elementary school. • One of the family secrets that may have
led to the creation of those “walls of mystery” that Kennedy says “surrounded
the facts of Marion’s early life”* was that she was apparently born out of wedlock. In March 2015, I discovered
that Benjamin Isaac Morehouse was previously married to Etta C. Harger (née Van
Dalson), on December 22, 1889. About fourteen months later, Etta, also known as
“Nettie,” gave birth to a son named Otto Morehouse, in February 1891.* And on February 26, 1902, “Nettie” and Benjamin were divorced. In 1903 Marion was born, and the following
year Benjamin married Marion’s mother, Anna Shortell, on June 30, 1904. The ceremony
was held in the neighboring state of Michigan, in Niles: about eleven miles north
of South Bend, Indiana. The marriage registry in Niles also includes the names
of the bride and groom’s parents; and it shows that, while Benjamin was residing
in South Bend, Anna was then living in Hartford. Under “Profession,” we learn
that Benjamin Morehouse was a “Showman.”* Another intriguing detail: the “Person Performing
[the] Marriage” bears the same surname as Benjamin’s mother: Justice of the Peace
W. I. Babcock. Further research revealed that his full name was Washington
Irving Babcock, a fifty-one-year-old resident of Niles. One of the witnesses to
the ceremony, Ruth (Hitchcock) Babcock, was Washington Irving’s wife. They were
each born in New York State in the 1830s and later emigrated to Niles, where Justice
Babcock also worked as a lumber dealer. How (or if) he is related to Benjamin’s
mother, Elizabeth Jane Babcock, remains unclear. But if he is related, it might
explain why Niles was chosen for the marriage ceremony. • When I subsequently rechecked the information
on the 1910 census for Benjamin and Anna, I noticed that, under “Marital Status,”
the notation “M1” appears beside Anna’s name; while Benjamin’s status is “M2.”
I then realized that the digits referred to their number of marriages,
thus showing Benjamin to be married twice. Yet, Benjamin’s enumerator has written
“7” under “Number of Years of Present Marriage,” even though the census was conducted
about two-and-a-half months short of their sixth wedding anniversary. • Earlier in his life, Benjamin lived
and worked mostly in South Bend, but he appears in Hartford during the years 1911
and 1912 and from 1945 to 1954.* Besides working as a vaudeville actor and a scenery setter for the theater,
Benjamin was employed as a carpenter and worked in various other working-class
positions: wood finisher, paper hanger, painter for the Studebaker Corporation
(manufacturer of the Studebaker automobile; the company was based in South Bend
and was founded by two local blacksmiths), stage hand, night porter, watchman,
janitor (during the Great Depression), maintenance man. (This despite Marion’s
tendency to pose as an aristocrat.)* The 1930 census shows that Benjamin received no schooling and that his
parents (John Morehouse and Elizabeth Jane Babcock) were each born and raised
in Indiana. Civil War records note that a “John Morehouse” was “enlisted in the
Indiana 11th Light Artillery Battery on 17 December 1861 and mustered out on 7
January 1865,” although it’s unclear whether this was the same person. John married
Elizabeth Jane in June 1865, and he fathered seven children, of which Benjamin
was the third. • Marion Morehouse’s mother, Anna Shortell, was born in Hartford, as was Anna’s father, William. William’s parents, John Shortell and Mary Berry, were from Ireland. William’s wife was named Anna Halpin, and she hailed from London. Her father, William Halpin, was also born in England; and his wife, Elizabeth Dryden, was from Ireland. Hence, the Anglo-Irish cast of Marion and Lillian’s appearance. • Marion’s parents married each other a second time on December 20, 1918, in the Church of St. Francis de Sales, on East 96th Street in the Bronx. Although there’s a record of Benjamin’s divorce from his previous marriage, there’s no record in the South Bend county clerk’s office of a divorce between Benjamin and Anna Shortell, so it's possible that their 1918 marriage was simply performed as a religious ceremony. Since Anna and Benjamin both vanish
from Indiana and Connecticut directories around this time, there remains a strong
possibility that the family relocated to New York. I could find no trace of Benjamin
in Indiana or Connecticut directories from 1913 to 1924; while Anna disappears
from these listings between 1915 and 1927. A 1927 Hartford directory notes that
a Benjamin and Anna Morehouse were “removed” from the directory after a relocation
to New York City, but it’s uncertain as to whether this is the same Morehouse
couple. But they eventually returned to Indiana, and, according to a 1928 South
Bend city directory, were living at 128 North Lafayette Street. Marion
could have attended school at St. Francis de Sales (in 1918 she was fifteen years
old; Lillian twelve; and Benjamin Junior eight), since at that time the church
hosted a school. Although Kennedy has conjectured that Marion and Lillian came
to New York on their own in the Twenties in order to break into the theater, it
may have been a family relocation that first brought them to Manhattan. • Marion performed on the Broadway
stage as early as 1923, at the age of twenty; Lillian in musical revues in 1925,
when she was nineteen. Thanks to the online Playbill
Vault and the Internet Broadway
Database, we know that Marion acted in at least five
Broadway plays between October 1923 and January 1931, which ran for a total
of 412 performances. (Kennedy says Marion “was able to get jobs as
a showgirl in one or another of the musical revues such as the Ziegfeld Follies
or to find bit parts here or there in plays,” but the only play he mentions by
name is “Gilbert Seldes’s adaptation of Lysistrata in
1930”: Marion’s fifth Broadway production, which ran from June 5, 1930 to January
1931.)*
The records also show that Lillian
performed in two musical revues,
Earl Carroll’s 1924 and 1925 Vanities (a competitor of Ziegfeld), and a
musical comedy, Lucky, with a total of 403 shows between September 1924
and May 1927.*
(Lucky was featured at the New Amsterdam Theatre, which also hosted the
Ziegfeld Follies.) But since the archives contain only Broadway shows,
there may have been other, Off-Broadway productions that featured the Morehouse
sisters: a possibility that’s bolstered by Tony Ungaro’s comment that Lillian
and Marion “appeared together on the stage” (see below). The earliest Steichen photo of Marion
that I’ve seen so far dates from 1924 (see below): the same year that Marion was
discovered by Vogue during a model search organized for Jean Patou. Since
Steichen frequented the theater and the burlesque, it’s possible the famous photographer
also saw Marion perform in one of her early dramatic plays. For example, on December
26, 1923, Marion appeared in This
Fine-Pretty World at the Neighborhood Playhouse, at 466 Grand Street. After
thirty-three shows, it closed in January 1924. And later that year she
performed in a play called “The Saint,” which opened on October 11, 1924, at the
Greenwich Village Theatre on Seventh Avenue South, near Christopher Street, in
Cummings’s neck of the woods. After seventeen performances, it closed that same
month. Steichen also might have encountered Marion at the Ziegfeld Follies
or in some other musical revue.*
Kennedy says that Marion’s tall, lanky figure made it difficult for her to find
theatrical parts, but it was perfect for the role of a “showgirl.” His 1978 interview
with Marion’s friend Aline Macmahon seems to have been the source of this information:
“Because Marion was very tall,” he writes, “she
had a hard time finding roles to play on the stage, although her height and beauty
were very suitable for work she secured as a showgirl in the Ziegfeld Follies.
Lillian, an attractive blonde, was also a showgirl for Ziegfeld.”*
When I mentioned the Ziegfeld Follies to Tony Ungaro, however, he said
he could recall no evidence of their employment with Ziegfeld in the papers he’d
inherited but added that his memory was fuzzy when it came to the names of particular
shows. Although the Playbill Vault has a complete archive of opening-night performers
for the Ziegfeld Follies from 1907 to 1957, neither Marion nor Lillian
appear there. Still, there’s a possibility they were hired as replacements later
on, after opening night. Although
Marion claims to have met Cummings following her performance in a play on June
23, 1932, she never revealed the title of this production to Kennedy: a highly
suspicious omission. If they met after a Ziegfeld Follies-type of revue
(Cummings was known to use dance hall-related material in his poetry), perhaps
Marion considered such a venue to be lacking the glamour of the more “artful”
theater. In keeping with her flamboyant persona, she may have felt the need to
embellish upon this legendary encounter with one of America’s most well known
poets. However, all this remains speculative. •
Benjamin Isaac Morehouse’s death certificate lists one of the causes of his demise
as “rheumatoid arthritis”: a malady that can be passed along genetically. Therefore,
Marion, who suffered terribly from this debilitating illness, may have inherited
it from her father.
* * * Something
that cannot be captured by mere vital statistics is the effect that Marion had
upon the heart and soul of the poet. When we finally conducted our interview on
February 2, 2015, I asked Christopher to describe her relationship with Cummings
and to elaborate on how they supported each other emotionally and artistically.
“That
story,” he replied, “begins with two other relationships before that. The first
woman he falls in love with is Elaine, who was married to his friend Scofield
Thayer. Scofield, as we know now, and as I’m sure Cummings knew at the time, was,
if not ‘bi,’ gay.” “And
very much in the closet for a while.” “Yes.
An esthete, but not particularly interested in his wife sexually. Cummings falls
head over heels in love with Elaine, with Scofield’s wife. And Elaine herself
is upper-crust. She’s not the easiest person in the world to get along with; nor
was, I think, Estlin himself. But basically, they have an affair, and she gets
pregnant with Cummings’s child. Thayer, being Cummings’s best friend, knows what’s
going on, but he adopts the child – or rather, he allows it to be born as if it’s
his daughter. Eventually, Elaine and Thayer are divorced. Elaine marries Cummings,
and it does not last very long. There are just too many differences between them.
The daughter doesn’t realize at the time that she’s his child: that Cummings is
her real father. They part ways; Elaine goes off to Ireland, and Cummings is bereft.
I mean, he’s absolutely bereft that Elaine has fallen in love with someone else
and left him after he was hoping that this was going to be the love of his life. “For
all of Cummings’s ‘sexual identity’ as a poet – because he certainly has one because
of all the erotic poems, and being one of the first to write poems that were unabashedly
not just about love, but about sex – people think he must have had a million women. Well, he didn’t.
He had only three principal women.
And they were each enormously important to him. He was a very tender, very sentimental,
and, in that way, very ‘son of his father’ old-fashioned man. Then he hooks up
with Anne Barton, who is a flapper and totally unfaithful from the moment they
get together, and this kills Cummings as well. “He
loves women as women, and I’ll try to clarify what I mean by this. He enjoyed
being in women’s company. Probably among his closest friends was Hildegarde Watson,
who was married to his friend James Watson. I don’t believe there was ever a sexual
attraction on either’s part, but he absolutely adored being in her company. He
adored women. He enjoyed who they were. He enjoyed the way they smelled
[Laughs]. He enjoyed the way they looked, the way they walked. And so, in a pretty
tough period for Cummings – financially, he’s not doing well; he never did well,
and his mother generally supported him most of his life – but here he is, a ‘two-time
loser’ if you will, and suddenly here comes this angel out of the fog, Marion
Morehouse. She is young. She is, unlike Elaine or Anne, really interested in being
with Cummings.” “And
not a gold digger, like Anne.” “Not
a gold digger like Anne was, certainly. And so, she is gorgeous, and she makes
it pretty clear, pretty early on, that what she wants to do is take care of this
great man. And, wow! [Laughs] He’s finally found the love of his life.
“Who
knows what takes place in those kinds of circumstances? But clearly, there was
a tremendous attraction. I didn’t write this, because I didn’t have enough evidence,
but, from the little that I could glean, he was attracted to her initially because
she was so gorgeous. It was certainly a major physical attraction. I think it
took a while for him to let his guard down so that he could see her in a larger
way. He kept her at a distance, initially; he wasn’t quite sure of what to do.
“And
so, what we have is hundreds of pages of writing about Elaine, maybe a hundred
or so pages about Anne, but we have only about twenty pages about Marion. Why?
Because he doesn’t have to exorcise the demons. What he’s doing with writing about
Elaine and about Anne is trying to exorcise those demons. Because he wrote everything
down; he was compulsive about trying to think on paper. You could see the guy
pacing about the room, smoking endless cigarettes, then writing something down
to help him try to analyze things. Once he meets Marion, this goes away. He writes
about other things, but he’s not obsessing about his relationship any longer.
And that, in a way, tells you how perfectly matched they were. “What happened as they spent more
time together … I would say she became much more of a ‘gatekeeper’ for Cummings.
Allen Ginsberg told me a story: He’d gone to Cummings’s house and knocked on the
door, and no one answered. And he’d written him a letter and sent him a copy of
“Howl.” He really wanted Cummings’s approval; it was enormously important to him
for some reason. He finally gets to Patchin Place again, on another occasion,
and he knocks on the door, and Marion comes down the stairs, takes one look, and
says: “You. Go away. And never come back.” He tries to explain
who he is, and she just … She was the gatekeeper. And that was very much
a part of her function in later years. And with Cummings’s blessing, because he
became more of a curmudgeon as he got older. And by ‘older,’ I mean fifty-five.
The man didn’t live all that long. And she became ‘the one you had to get through.’ “I believe her political views really
began to affect Cummings’s. She was very much a right-winger. At that time, Lindberg
was on the radio, and various other right-wing isolationist, “Keep Out of World
War Two” folks. And she would get Cummings to listen to these broadcasts, because
these were the ones who were ‘telling the truth.’ She absolutely hated Roosevelt.
Hard to know why; she was hardly an aristocrat! She hardly had any money, and
she certainly had no reason to be a Republican, but then … Oh, well! “So, she’s a model. She’s in Vogue.
And she’s an artist’s model: Steichen. At about the time she meets Cummings,
it’s likely she was also trying to achieve more in the theater. But suddenly she
moves from being a sort of career woman – because she was certainly building a
career – to being Cummings’s protector and supporter.”* And
I think no one has ever said it better than that. * * * After
accumulating these various facts and anecdotes, on March 21, a day before his
eighty-second birthday, I contacted Tony Ungaro for a follow-up interview. I asked
him to go over the story once more, and I began by asking what year he’d first
encountered Lillian. “In
1960,” he said, “I went to work for Heublein, Inc., and she was working in Central
Files, as a file clerk.” He offered her a ride home “within that year, and it
was just occasionally. She was living with her brother.” “Do
you know anything about the relationship between Lillian and Marion? Were they
close?” “Well,
they appeared together on the stage.” At this my ears perked up. This was new
information, and it might explain the nature of one particular image in Tony’s
collection in which the sisters are each heavily made up and wearing what appear
to be theatrical costumes. “I don’t think there was any problem between them,
frankly. Marion went her way, and Lillian went hers. And when Marion passed away
… Well, Marion’s husband had passed away first: E. E. Cummings. And of course,
Marion inherited everything. When Marion passed away, she left, to Lillian, the
income from his work. She continued to receive that. I think after Marion passed
away, E. E. Cummings’s daughter …” “The
last time we spoke, you said you heard that the daughter was a bit angry about
that.” “Somewhere
along the line, I’d heard that. I don’t know how true it was. But I can believe
she would have been a little disappointed, to say the least.” “The
sisters performed together on the stage? I don’t think anyone else is aware of
that. Did you have some kind of documentation in the boxes that they were in a
play together?” “Yes.” “There’s
also speculation that they were employed as showgirls for the Ziegfeld Follies.” “That
I don’t recall. I had a whole bunch of papers, and playbills, and things like
that, which I sent to the family. I don’t recall the names of the shows. Lillian
was quite attractive. In fact, she resembled, in my opinion, the actress Lillian
Gish.” After
summarizing Kennedy’s search for embarrassing “family secrets,” I asked Tony a
few pointed questions about the inner dynamics of the Morehouse clan. “I’m wondering
if you know anything about Lillian’s relationship with her parents.” “I
don’t think there were any problems between the parents and Marion; I didn’t see
any evidence of that. I saw no evidence of family problems, frankly.” “And
what about Lillian and the parents? Any estrangement there?” “Not
that I’m aware of, or saw at all. And let me tell you, I had a ton … the
lawyer sent me three boxes of material that he had left. And I didn’t see any
evidence of that, frankly.” “Do
you know anything about what led to the parents’ initial separation?” “I
know the mother was in a hospital in New York, and the father was trying to …
You know, holding down the apartment in Hartford. And those were some very difficult
times.” Although I was referring to the possibility of an estrangement between
1908 and 1918, I soon realized that Tony was actually referring to a later period,
“in the Thirties,” he said, during the Great Depression. “Difficult
financially?” “Financially,
right. And I don’t know what specific years all this occurred, but there was that.
It was difficult days. There was some correspondence between the parents. The
father was in Hartford. And the mother was in some hospital in New York. I think
it was a charity ward; I’m not sure. All this would have been in the letters,
which I don’t have anymore.” (One wonders if this could have been St. Vincent’s
Hospital, which always catered to the poor and which was conveniently located
near Patchin Place, at Greenwich and Seventh Avenue.) At
this point, we returned to the subject of Lillian. “When she worked at Heublein,
I had to go right by her street. So when she was stuck for a ride, she asked if
I’d drop her off. I said ‘Certainly, it’s right on my way.’ After she left Heublein,
I sent Christmas cards and things like that. Her brother was still alive, and
living with her. I think he worked part time, in a movie theater right up the
street.*
Other than these occasional communications, I never really saw her. Then I got
a letter from the probate court, saying I have ‘an interest,’ and blah-blah-blah.
And I said, ‘What the hell interest could I possibly have?’ [Laughs] You know,
this woman didn’t really have much; she worked as a clerk … as far as I knew.
She was living in this two- or three-family house. Then I called the lawyer, and
he told me she’d remembered me in her will, along with this doctor, and two women
who had helped her with her brother in later years. And she remembered everybody
in her will. So I called the doctor, and he said, “Yeah, it was kind of strange,
because when I told her I was moving out of state, she said, ‘Why’d you take me
out of the picture for, if you knew you were going to move?’ [Laughs] And I said,
‘That sounds like Lillian.’ “After
all was said and done, I think there was about four thousand dollars left to be
distributed. I was initially left ten grand. And I said to the lawyer: ‘I don’t
need the money. I want to make sure she has a proper stone and all that.’ He said,
‘That
was all taken care of.’ She’s buried with her parents at Mount Saint Benedict
Hospital, in Bloomfield. That’s where my parents are, and grandparents, and the
whole family. “I
had 1040s, tax forms, in that pile of papers, and I could see where Lillian was
getting the royalties from E. E. Cummings’s work. Twenty thousand dollars, or
something like that, a year. And that’s how she managed to build up her inheritance
if you will. But a lot of it went out for caretakers for her and her brother.
She didn’t die wealthy.” Tony
spoke with a palpable affection for Lillian and with a lingering fascination with
her past. “I’ll bet you regret not having spent more time with her while she was
alive,” I said, “and getting to know her better.” “Well,
yeah, in view of her history, which I had no knowledge of when I knew her at Heublein.
When I started going through those boxes, I was floored. It was amazing. Full
of photographic albums, pictures that went back easily into the 1800s. Which I
wasn’t going to throw away, and I had no use for. And I was … ‘What the hell am
I going to do with all this?’ My conscience wouldn’t let me destroy it, other
than the very personal letters between Marion’s mother and father. So I tracked
down relatives in Indiana, and I sent all that material to them. And what they
did with it, I have no idea. But there were all kind of playbills from the shows,
pictures of her in costume, and … oh!” “Pictures
of Lillian and Marion in costume?” “Yeah,
on the stage. I think Marion was also in some movie. A small part with Lionel
Barrymore. Whether she got credit for it or not on screen … But there was something;
she was in Hollywood. And there were some letters she wrote that were not too
kind to some people.” [Laughs] “Not
too kind to people in the film?” “No,
in the movie industry. Written to a friend or family; I can’t recall which. It’s
been a number of years now, you know? And there was something in there, I believe
it was a film with Lionel Barrymore, back in the Twenties.” As far as I know,
this is the first compelling evidence that Marion had appeared in a Hollywood
film. (Charles Norman, a friend of Cummings and Marion and the author of the authorized
biography, E. E. Cummings, says that Marion was in two films that were
shot in Long Island. But since Marion was the probable source of this information,
this must be taken with a grain of salt.* )
“She
was obviously a talented woman. Too bad you didn’t contact me fifteen years ago.
I would have had a lot more information, and I would have made it available to
you. What a book you could have written … You would have had a great time!” After
wishing Tony a Happy Birthday, he passed along the name and address of one of
Marion’s relatives in Indiana. “Maybe she can help you.” Thus,
the search for the elusive model, muse, and starlet continues. * * * Although this brief genealogical
foray into Marion’s distant past represents only a minor footnote to the work
completed by Richard Kennedy and Christopher Sawyer-Lauçanno, perhaps it will
help future biographers to uncover more of the colorful history of the Marion
Morehouse family.
Documents and Photos:
Photographs
from the Tony Ungaro Collection:
|
• Anna (Shortell) Morehouse (left) and daughter Marion (right). If Marion was fifty years old here, the photo would be circa 1953, making her mother about seventy-three. This is the only known image of Marion with her mother, and, like most of the photos that follow, it has never before been made publicly available. |
•
A young Marion Morehouse, her hair gathered
in an elegant up-sweep, wearing a black wool jacket trimmed in mink over a
bias-cut red silk dress, with draped wrap neckline and accessorized with
leather gloves and a jeweled bracelet. I have not yet identified the photographer,
although the style appears to be that of Steichen’s. Steichen usually shot in
black and white, but he began to experiment with color in the mid-1930s, utilizing
more of an informal, “snapshot” composition. Since color photographs first appeared
in 1935, Marion would have been at least thirty-two years old. |
• Lillian Morehouse. (One of three photos that Tony Ungaro uploaded
to “Find-a-Grave.) |
•
The only known image of Marion’s father, |
•
Lillian Morehouse, in later years. |
•
Marion’s brother, Benjamin W. Morehouse. |
•
Marion’s mother, Anna Shortell, |
• Left to right: Benjamin Morehouse, Jr; Anna (Shortell) Morehouse; Lillian Morehouse. (One of three photos that Tony Ungaro uploaded to “Find-a-Grave.) |
•
The poet Edward Estlin Cummings, the lifelong partner of Marion Morehouse, in
front of a barn at Joy Farm, his New Hampshire retreat. The photo was taken by
Marion Morehouse. (Note the inscription: “E. E. Cummings 1939,” on top left.)
|
•Lillian
Morehouse, her hair in a styled bob, modeling a satin dress with |
•
Marion (left) and Lillian (right): The only known photo of the sisters together,
and perhaps the earliest extant image of Marion Morehouse. According to Tony Ungaro,
Lillian and Marion performed together on stage. This image appears to have been
professionally composed, and it may have been taken while they were working together. |
•
An early photo of Lillian and her brother, Benjamin W. Morehouse. |
Lysistrata
Opening date: June 5, 1930. Closing date: January 1931.
Total Performances: 252.
Marion Morehouse: Second
Corinthian Woman.
Produced by Philadelphia
Theatre Association. Adapted by Gilbert Seldes. Choreographed by Doris Humphrey
and Charles Weidman. Staged by Norman Bel Geddes. Music by Leo Ornstein and Reinhold
Gliere.
44th Street Theatre, 216
W. 44th St., New York, NY.
Seats: 1465.
Built: 1912. Closed: 1945.
Demolished: 1945.
Mr. Moneypenny
Opening Date: October 17,
1928. Closing Date: December 1928.
Total Performances: 61.
Marion Morehouse: Iris; The
Dead Woman.
Comedy, written by Channing
Pollock. Directed by Richard Boleslavsky.
Liberty Theatre, 234 W. 42nd
St., New York, NY.
Seats: 1055.
Built: 1904. Closed: 1933.
The Saint
Drama, written by Stark Young.
Opening Date: October 11,
1924. Closing Date: October 1924.
Total Performances: 17.
Marion Morehouse: Daughters.
Greenwich Village Theatre
(later named the “Irish Theatre” in 1929), 7th Avenue South, near Christopher
Street, New York, NY.
Seats: 425
Built: 1917.
This Fine-Pretty World
Drama written by Percy MacKaye.
Opening Date: December 26,
1923. Closing Date: January 1924.
Total Performances: 33.
Marion Morehouse: Delphy
Boggs.
Neighborhood Playhouse, 466
Grand St., New York, NY.
Built: 1915. Demolished:
1927.
The Player Queen
Farce, written by William
Butler Yeats.
Opening Date: October 16,
1923. Closing Date: November 1923.
Total Performances: 49.
Marion Morehouse: Second
Countryman.
Neighborhood Playhouse,
466 Grand St., New York, NY.
Courtesy of the Playbill Vault and the Internet Broadway Database:
•
The 44th Street Theatre, where Marion appeared in
Lysistrata. |
•
A page from a 1928 Playbill for Mr.
Moneypenny,
which lists Marion in the role of “Iris.” |
•
In Act Two of Mr.
Moneypenny, Marion appears as “The Dead Woman.” |
•
The Liberty Theatre, which featured Marion in Mr.
Moneypenny. |
• Playbill for Lucky, March 22, 1927, which lists Lillian as one of the “Showgirls.” |
• The New Amsterdam Theatre (where Lillian appeared in Lucky) also hosted the Ziegfeld Follies. |
Musical, comedy, Broadway.
Opening date: March 22,
1927. Closing date: May 21, 1927.
Total Performances: 71.
Lillian Morehouse: Ensemble
performer.
Book by Otto Harbach. Music
by Jerome Kern. Musical Director: Gus Salzer. Music orchestrated by Robert Russell
Bennett. Lyrics by Otto Harbac. Staged by Hassard Short. Choreographed by David
Bennett. Ballets arranged by Albertina Rasch.
New Amsterdam Theatre, 214
West 42nd St., New York, NY.
Seats: 1747.
Built:
1903.
Earl Carroll’s Vanities
of 1925
Musical, revue, Broadway.
Opening date: July 6, 1925.
Closing date: December 27, 1925.
Total Performances: 199.
Lillian Morehouse: Ensemble
performer.
Produced
by Earl Carroll. Music by Clarence Gaskill.
Book by William A. Grew, et al.
Music interpreted by Ross Gorman. Musical
Director: Donald Voorhees. Staged by William
A. Grew.
Earl Carroll Theatre, 753 Seventh Ave. (West 50th St.), New York, NY.
Seats: 1025.
Built: 1922. Closed: 1939.
Demolished: 1990.
Earl Carroll’s Vanities
of 1924
Musical, revue, Broadway.
Opening date: September
10, 1924. Closing date: January 3, 1925.
Total Performances: 133.
Lillian Morehouse: Ensemble
performer.
Music Box Theatre (September
10, 1924 – November 1924),
239 W. 45th St., New York,
NY.
Seats: 1009.
Built: 1921.
Earl Carroll Theatre (November
10, 1924 – January 3, 1925)
(Thanks to the Internet
Broadway Database, the Playbill Vault, and the Internet Movie Database for the
information contained in these chronologies.)
____________________
*
*
Tobia Bezzola, “Lights Going All
Over the Place,” from William A. Ewing and Todd Brandow, Edward Steichen: In
High Fashion, The Condé Nast Years, 1923-1937 (W. W. Norton and Company, 2008),
p. 192. Published for the international exhibition of the same name that was organized
by the Foundation for the Exhibition of Photography, Minneapolis, and the Musée
de l’Elysée, Lausanne. The collection was exhibited in eight different museums
between 2007 and 2009, and it featured four photos of Marion Morehouse.
*
Harold Koda, The Model as
Muse: Embodying Fashion (New York: Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2009), pp.
19-21. Published in conjunction with an eponymously titled exhibit at the Metropolitan
Museum of Art (May 6-August 9, 2000).
*
A more accurate
description would be: “not a famous model,” but the point is well taken.
Robin Muir, “Vogue’s Earliest Celebrity Models,” FirstFT magazine, September
24, 2010, ft.com.
*
The earliest Steichen photo of Marion that
Richard Kennedy seems to have been aware of is the one that appeared in Vogue
on October 15, 1925 (“Model Marion Morehouse wearing a dress by Lelong and Jewelry
by Black, Starr and Frost”). The portrait is reproduced in Richard Kennedy’s E.
E. Cummings Revisited (New York: Twayne Publishers, 1994), on page 112. In
the words of Sawyer-Lauçanno, the photos from this period “reveal an absolutely
stunning young woman, with large brown eyes, long dark hair, perfect full lips,
and a Roman nose. By the early 1930s, her career as a fashion model was well established
and she was in high demand.” E. E. Cummings, A Biography (Naperville, IL:
Sourcebooks, 2004), p. 363. In Dreams in the Mirror, Kennedy calls her
“one of the great beauties of her time,” noting her “long elliptical face,” “high
cheek bones,” “swanlike neck,” “delicately curved breasts.” Echoing Steichen,
Kennedy notes: “Her training in the theater helped her to become a renowned fashion
model, for she had the knack of adapting herself to the character of the clothes
that were chosen for her.” Kennedy, Dreams in the Mirror. A Biography of E.
E. Cummings (New York: Liveright Publishing Corporation, 1980), p. 337.
*
Although
a marriage of seven years would have made Marion’s birth legitimate, Benjamin
and Anna were actually married for about six years at this time.
*
Kennedy,
“The Elusive Marion Morehouse,” Spring. The Journal of the E. E. Cummings Society
(Flushing, NY: E. E. Cummings Society, 1996), Number 5, p. 9.
*
Otto
Leo Morehouse was employed as a chauffeur and taxi driver during the Great Depression
(while his father was a janitor) and later as a clerk. He died three months before
Marion, in February 1969.
*
A
county clerk from South Bend informed me that crossing over the state line in
order to marry after a divorce was a common practice; otherwise, one might be
forced to wait up to two years to marry again within the state. Anna’s surname
appears here as “Shortelle.” Lillian Morehouse’s birth certificate says that Benjamin
worked as “shoeman” (sic). Most likely, the person gathering the information mistook
the (spoken) word “showman” for “shoe man.”
*
Since
the information contained in city directories is gathered during the year prior
to their publication, a listing in a “1904” directory actually reflects a person’s
residence and employment status in 1903.
*
“In
her social views, she posed as a ‘monarchist’ and an ‘aristocrat’ and often offered
her opinions with hauteur. Like many people lacking in educational background,
she enjoyed looking down on others – working-class people or people outside their
social circles – in order to elevate herself.” Kennedy, “The Elusive Marion Morehouse,”
p. 12.
*
Kennedy, Dreams,
p. 337. According to the Playbill
Archive, the play “Lysistrata” starred Hortense Alden (from the New York Theater
Guild), who made her Broadway debut as a teenager and who performed in fifteen
Broadway productions between 1919 and 1939. She would later appear in a 1964 episode
of the TV serial, The Doctors and the Nurses (1962-1965).
In 1941, Hortense married James T. Farrell, author of the Studs Lonigan
trilogy. For more on the production
of Lysistrata, see my “Partial Chronology of Marion Morehouse’s
Theatrical Work.”
*
Although neither Morehouse sister appears in the online Ziegfeld Follies
archive, Lillian’s name is listed in two of Earl Carroll’s Vanities productions,
which were Ziegfeld Follies-like musical revues. Carroll constructed his
own Broadway venue, The Earl Carroll Theatre, which in 1925 featured Eugene O’Neill’s
premier of “Desire Under the Elms.” Carroll’s theater on Seventh Avenue was purchased
by Ziegfeld in 1932 and renamed the Casino Theatre. It later hosted the Woolworth’s
Department store. It was demolished in 1990.
Steichen’s widow, Joanna Steichen, briefly
mentions Marion and Cummings in her book, Steichen’s Legacy: “Once, Steichen
suggested making a series of nude photographs. Morehouse agreed and posed wearing
only long black gloves and stockings. Later, Steichen heard that she had married.
To save her any possibility of future embarrassment, he destroyed the negatives
of the nude sitting. Then he learned that she had married the avant-garde bohemian
poet e. e. cummings, who, Steichen believed, would have relished the pictures.”
Steichen’s Legacy (New York: Knopf,
2000), p. 106. Thanks to Christopher Sawyer-Lauçanno for alerting me to
the fact that Steichen and Cummings were friends.
*
Edward
Steichen: In High Fashion, The Condé Nast Years, 1923-1937 contains many portraits
of dancers, actors, and actresses from the early Twenties, including one captioned
“Actress Mary Eaton from the Follies, 1923”: the same year that Steichen arrived
in the United States. Plate 33 features one of the earliest photos of Marion taken
by Steichen and is captioned “Model Marion Morehouse wearing an evening gown by
Chanel, 1924.” This gelatin silver print first appeared in the February 15, 1925
edition of Vogue.
According to author Nancy Hall-Duncan,
Marion “was first seen in Steichen’s photograph of November 1, 1924 for American
Vogue. Nancy Hall-Duncan, The History of Fashion Photography (New
York: Alpine Book Company, 1979), p. 54. Considered a classic in the field, this
catalog was published in conjunction with the History of Fashion Photography exhibit
produced by the author for the International Museum of Photography at the George
Eastman House in Rochester, New York. The exhibit also traveled to several other
museums in the United States.
*
Kennedy,
“The Elusive Marion Morehouse,” p. 9.
*
This
was the same conclusion reached by Cummings’s friend Charles Norman, who says,
“When she married Cummings, she put her career behind her.” Charles Norman, E.
E. Cummings: A Biography (New York: E. P. Dutton & Co., 1967), p.
10. Norman was personally acquainted with Cummings from 1925 until his death in
1962.
*
According
to Benjamin Jr’s death certificate, before he retired he was employed at the Webster
Theater in Hartford. City directories list his occupation as “assistant manager.”
*
“She
appeared in two films, and I have heard that whenever she arrived on location,
in a Long Island studio, spectators and technicians ceased watching the stars
to watch her.” Charles Norman, E. E. Cummings, p. 10.
This essay was also published in More Collected Couteau: Essays and Interviews (Dominantstar, 2016), along with an interview with MIT Professor Christopher Sawyer-Laucanno, the renowned biographer of E. E. Cummings. Available on amazon. "Couteau's essays are often rhapsodic appreciations and evocations of the work under study, and are stuffed with both insights and joy." - James Dempsey, author of The Tortured Life of Scofield Thayer. From Publishers Weekly, BookLife: "Couteau's essays are informal, fervent, and well-versed examinations of the work or author at hand. At their best, they include fascinating insights into the significance of a writer like [Hubert] Selby.... The interviews are uniformly strong and include conversations with Michael Korda on T.E. Lawrence, Justin Kaplan on Walt Whitman, and Robert Roper on Vladimir Nabokov. Not all of them focus on literature: author Jeffrey Jackson covers the 1910 flood of Paris and why it's relatively forgotten, and Robert De Sena, in one of the best interviews, discusses his life as a gang member turned community activist. Couteau's passion and wealth of knowledge are obvious throughout the book ... and should appeal to many readers." From the Midwest Book Review: "The joy of reading Couteau's works lies as much in his penetrating, crystalline language as it does in the works or figures being examined, and so readers receive a wide-ranging treat that examines victims, vengeance, mortality and immortality through an inspection process that educates even those unfamiliar with the subject [...] Readers seeking not just a literary presentation but a lively analysis of selected wordsmiths and their lives and influences must add More Collected Couteau to their reading lists. It's a powerful presentation that offers much insight and food for thought, and which should find its way into many a college classroom as well." Available on amazon. Contact: rob_couteau@yahoo.com |
Since: 28 May 2015 | Copyright © 2017 Rob Couteau |
key words: South Bend Indiana Lillian Morehouse Edward Steichen E. E. Cummings Marion Morehouse